Title and real estate disputes come up more often than people expect, especially once a foreclosure is already underway. A lien from a contractor who was never paid, a deed with a missing signature, a boundary line nobody surveyed properly, or a title insurer denying a claim after closing can all stall a sale, block a refinance, or complicate a foreclosure defense. In Marion County and the surrounding townships, these cases usually run through either the county recorder's office and title company first, then into Marion Superior Court if a lawsuit is needed to clear the title or force a resolution.
We track 49 attorneys and firms in the Indianapolis area who handle this kind of work, ranging from solo practitioners who mostly do quiet title actions and closing cleanup to larger firms that litigate contested ownership, easement fights, and lender disputes. That range matters because the right fit depends heavily on what you're actually dealing with. A defect flagged during a routine title search calls for a different skill set than a full quiet title lawsuit against an heir who surfaced after a probate closed, or a dispute with a title insurance company refusing to pay out on a policy.
Our ranked guide to Indianapolis real estate and title dispute attorneys scores every firm on the same factors: how they communicate, how consistently clients report good outcomes, how long they've practiced this specific area, and how they're viewed across public review sources. We built the scoring so you can compare firms on more than a star rating alone. The full breakdown of how we weigh each factor is on our methodology page.
Get matched with real estate & title disputes in Indianapolis
Free and no obligation. Tell us what you need, and we'll connect you with suitable attorneys in your area.
We found 49 businesses offering real estate & title disputes in Indianapolis; 17 met the criteria for the scored directory. The order weighs each business's overall score by how much of its reviewed work is real estate & title disputes, so a lower-scored specialist can rank above a higher-scored generalist.
Arie Lipinski resolves complex legal disputes by staying accessible and fighting hard through adversity. Clients praise his honesty, quick responses, and ability to deliver favorable outcomes even when other lawyers said the case was unwinnable.
This firm draws strong praise for its responsiveness, named attorneys like Jeff Hammond, Greg Laker, Amanda, and Skyler who clients describe as knowledgeable and genuinely invested in their cases. Staff keep clients updated consistently, explain legal matters clearly, and handle emotional situations with care. One complainant reported poor communication and unresolved issues, noting plans to escalate to the State Bar, but this represents a stark minority against overwhelming five-star reviews praising settlement outcomes, court victories, and thorough case management. The firm lists personal injury, medical malpractice, wrongful death, car and truck accidents, premises liability, and sexual abuse cases on its website. Clients specifically named Jeff Hammond, Greg Laker, Greg, Amanda, Skyler, Chad, Tara, Brett B. Thomas, and others. Reviewers highlight quick settlements, closure without courtroom appearances, support through traumatic cases, and follow-up care like holiday cards. The firm operates in Mile Square, Indianapolis.
Ashley Dayhuff and Bob Nice lead a firm known for deep case preparation and calm reassurance through legal crises. Most clients credit them with turning cases around or protecting their interests, yet three one-star reviews flag sudden attorney departures, unexpected fee demands, and communication breakdowns that left families worse off financially and legally. Heather Ressler earns consistent praise for estate planning efficiency. The firm operates across multiple Indiana counties and publishes a broad service menu; however, consistency appears to hinge on which attorney draws your case. Long-term clients report sustained excellence, while newer clients sometimes encounter staffing chaos.
Striebeck Law handles title work and real estate disputes with consistent speed and expertise. Reviewers highlight attorney responsiveness, transparent billing, and staff who explain each step clearly. Named attorneys Eileen Maguire and Amy Cueller earn praise for thoroughness and patience through multi-year cases. Two reviewers flagged high fees relative to limited scope and an uncomfortable initial intake request, though those remain outliers in a largely five-star track record. The firm's website lists quiet title, probate, foreclosure, and notarization services. Wait times appear measured in weeks for straightforward matters; one reviewer completed a quit claim and heirship documentation in under a month. Staff includes paralegals Lorene and Heather, who reviewers describe as attentive to timelines and case explanations.
Most clients praise named attorneys like Sean Moore and Brad Cohen for responsiveness, thoroughness, and clear explanations. However, the firm occasionally declines cases citing distance, and older reviews flag unprofessional conduct by specific staff members, suggesting uneven service quality across the practice.
Get matched with real estate & title disputes in Indianapolis
Free and no obligation. Tell us what you need, and we'll connect you with suitable attorneys in your area.
Reviewers highlight Attorney Peter Ten Eyck's ability to untangle complex, years-long legal problems that other lawyers had left unresolved. His direct approach and quick responses earned consistent five-star marks.
Established real estate attorney with strong praise from long-term clients for expertise in property matters, but recent reviews flag persistent issues with phone responsiveness and fee transparency. Those who reach her praise her work; those who cannot reach her leave frustrated.
Strong praise from satisfied clients centers on named attorneys who pursue cases with personal investment and deep legal knowledge. However, one-star reviews cite major settlement failings, failure to deliver reports, and intimidation when clients questioned handling errors, creating a split picture.
Griffith Xidias splits sharply: clients who connect report skilled work and successful results, with attorney Matt Griffith and staff member Patty earning praise. Others face weeks of silence and unfinished tasks, leaving them feeling abandoned. The firm has operated since 1993 and serves Indianapolis-area clients, but consistency appears uneven.
Mann Law helped some clients resolve legal issues fast and saved money, with staff praised as knowledgeable. Others report poor communication after hire, unclear billing, and needing to chase down status updates repeatedly.
A long-time client returned multiple times for legal help and reported good results each time. Review evidence is limited to one detailed account.
Three reviewers consistently describe Thomas Rothe as knowledgeable and detail-oriented, with family referrals and repeat clients returning for bankruptcy and consultation work. Limited review data; no negative feedback present.
Large firm attracts strong praise for expertise but faces repeated complaints about slow communication, unresponsive staff, and billing inconsistencies. Time-sensitive matters and small-town clients report particular friction with delays and lack of follow-up.
One reviewer gave a five-star rating. Review detail is limited, but the business's website shows experience in real estate title work since 1993.
Reviewers report stark contrasts. Some praise fast, thorough handling of real estate and probate issues and describe the attorney as knowledgeable and professional. Others note unreturned calls, lack of case preparation, and errors on filings. A handful report requesting payment before reviewing documents or understanding the case scope. Limited detail on foreclosure-specific services; most feedback covers real estate transactions, probate, and title disputes. Rating volatility (56% five-star, 33% one-to-two-star) reflects this inconsistency.
Review evidence is limited. The business operates in Mile Square, Indianapolis, and their website lists services in eminent domain law, property condemnation, and related real estate matters across central Indiana counties since 1968.
Not enough recent reviews yet to synthesise a reliable sentiment read for this business.
Enquiries submitted through our quote and contact forms may be passed to partner providers who can perform the work. We may receive a referral fee for these introductions, but our rankings and scores are determined solely by our published method and are never influenced by referral fees.
Last updated 2026-08-27