Best real estate & title disputes attorneys in Indianapolis
These are the 15 Indianapolis attorneys who treat real estate and title disputes as core work rather than a side offering, ranked by our methodology, which weighs review sentiment, volume, recency, and rating together.
Looking for foreclosure-specific help instead? See our best foreclosure attorney overall list, ranked separately since that's a distinct legal track from quiet title and boundary work.
Picks are ranked by score and relevance to real estate & title disputes, so a lower overall score can rank higher here.
At a glance
| # | Business | Score | Rating | From | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Lipinski Law | 86 | 5 (48) | — | Cases other lawyers turned down |
| 2 | CohenMalad, LLP | 85 | 4.7 (188) | — | Complex disputes needing a full firm |
| 3 | The Nice Law Firm, LLP | 83 | 4.6 (276) | — | Multi-county Indiana coverage |
| 4 | Striebeck Law PC | 81 | 4.8 (57) | — | Title work and quiet title claims |
| 5 | Cohen Garelick & Glazier | 66 | 4 (23) | — | Preparation-heavy negotiations |
| 6 | Berkshire Law LLC | 63 | 4 (26) | — | Real estate investors and property managers |
| 7 | Bose McKinney & Evans LLP | 62 | 3.7 (12) | — | Established firm backing on bigger disputes |
| 8 | Hackman Hulett, LLP | 61 | 5 (6) | — | Untangling years-long disputes |
| 9 | Griffith Xidias Law Group LLC | 60 | 3.8 (16) | — | Real estate and business law crossover |
| 10 | Mann Law, P.C. Attorneys at Law | 59 | 3.9 (51) | — | Quick, budget-conscious resolutions |
| 11 | Thomas Rothe, Attorney at Law | 58 | 5 (3) | — | Detail-oriented bankruptcy-adjacent title issues |
| 12 | Taft Stettinius & Hollister LLP | 58 | 3.5 (23) | — | Multi-state matters needing firm resources |
| 13 | Whitham, Hebenstreit, and Zubek | 57 | 4.3 (4) | — | Clients who value a long-term relationship |
| 14 | Attorney Janet Davis Hocker | 54 | 5 (1) | — | Longtime title work since the early 1990s |
| 15 | Irwin J. Prince, Attorney | 52 | 3.6 (9) | — | Probate-adjacent title disputes, with caution |
Ranked picks
Lipinski Law
Why it ranks first
Arie Lipinski built a perfect 5-star record across 48 reviews by taking on disputes other attorneys called unwinnable and still delivering favorable outcomes. Clients single out his honesty and same-day responsiveness, which is rare at this review volume and pushes him to the top of the composite.
Pros
- Takes on dismissed or 'unwinnable' cases
- Same-day answers to legal questions
- Clear, no-pressure explanation of options
- Sticks to stated fees and timelines
Watch out: Verification on the listing is still on the lower side, so confirm current case capacity directly.
Services: loan modification loss mitigation, real estate title issues, legal services, foreclosure service
CohenMalad, LLP
Why it ranks second
CohenMalad backs up its scale, 188 reviews at a 4.7 average, with named attorneys like Jeff Hammond and Greg Laker who clients say stay genuinely engaged through settlements and court outcomes. It's the highest-volume, highest-confidence pick on this list.
Pros
- Named attorneys clients specifically request
- Fast, consistent case updates
- Track record of settlements without trial
- Handles emotionally difficult cases with care
Watch out: One client reported a communication breakdown serious enough to consider a State Bar complaint, though this is an outlier against a large positive review base.
Services: foreclosure defense litigation, free consultation, loan modification loss mitigation, real estate title issues
The Nice Law Firm, LLP
Why it ranks third
The Nice Law Firm carries the largest review base on this list (276 reviews, 4.6 average) and clients credit Bob Nice and Ashley Dayhuff with thorough prep and calm guidance under pressure. Heather Ressler draws specific praise for estate-related efficiency, rounding out a firm built for scale across Indiana counties.
Pros
- Deep case prep and document review
- Experienced named attorneys across specialties
- Calm, compassionate handling of stressful matters
- Serves multiple counties, not just Marion
Watch out: A handful of one-star reviews describe sudden attorney departures and unexpected mid-case fee demands, so outcomes can hinge on which attorney is assigned.
Services: loan modification loss mitigation, real estate title issues, legal services
Striebeck Law PC
Why it ranks fourth
Striebeck Law is the clearest title specialist on this list, with quiet title, probate, and foreclosure work backed by a 4.8 rating over 57 reviews. Attorneys Eileen Maguire and Amy Cueller get specific praise for thoroughness, and one reviewer had a quit claim and heirship matter done in under a month.
Pros
- Fast turnaround on title and quit claim filings
- Named attorneys known for thoroughness and patience
- Paralegals Lorene and Heather keep clients on schedule
- Fees explained upfront
Watch out: A couple of reviewers flagged high fees for the scope of work and an awkward initial intake experience.
Services: loan modification loss mitigation, real estate title issues, foreclosure service
Cohen Garelick & Glazier
Why it ranks fifth
Cohen Garelick & Glazier earns solid marks (4.0 from 23 reviews) mainly through Sean Moore and Brad Cohen, who clients describe as thorough and responsive. The firm's willingness to handle complex matters spanning family law, trusts, and business transitions alongside real estate makes it a reasonable fit for disputes that cross into other legal areas.
Pros
- Sean Moore and Brad Cohen praised for preparation
- Clear explanation of legal steps
- Personalized attention reported by most clients
- Handles overlapping legal areas (trusts, business, family)
Watch out: The firm has reportedly declined cases based on distance or profitability, and professionalism has been inconsistent across staff in older reviews.
Services: foreclosure defense litigation, free consultation, legal services, loan modification loss mitigation
Berkshire Law LLC
Why it ranks sixth
Berkshire Law has built a reputation among investors and property managers for quiet title and complex transaction work, and clients who get through to her praise the quality of the work itself. The issue isn't competence, it's access, with recent reviews flagging a hard time getting calls returned.
Pros
- Strong track record with real estate investors
- Experience with quiet title and complex transactions
- Evening and weekend availability
- Fair pricing once engaged
Watch out: Recent reviews describe unreturned calls and unclear fee additions, so confirm response expectations before signing on.
Services: foreclosure defense litigation, free consultation, loan modification loss mitigation, real estate title issues
Bose McKinney & Evans LLP
Why it ranks seventh
Bose McKinney & Evans brings the weight of an established, broad-practice firm, and satisfied clients point to attorneys who invest personally in their cases. The review record is thin (12 reviews) and split, so this fits clients prioritizing firm stability over a spotless review history.
Pros
- Named attorneys with deep subject knowledge
- Personal investment in client cases reported
- Established, stable firm structure
Watch out: Some one-star reviews describe major settlement failings and unresponsiveness when clients raised concerns, so ask about escalation paths upfront.
Services: loan modification loss mitigation, debt collection defense, foreclosure defense litigation, free consultation
Hackman Hulett, LLP
Why it ranks eighth
Hackman Hulett's Peter Ten Eyck is called out repeatedly for resolving disputes that had sat unresolved for years under other attorneys. Reviews are few (6) but uniformly five-star and specific about his direct, responsive style.
Pros
- Reputation for unraveling long-stalled disputes
- Direct, no-nonsense communication
Watch out: Review volume is low, so treat the perfect rating as a promising signal rather than a settled track record.
Services: real estate title issues, loan modification loss mitigation
Griffith Xidias Law Group LLC
Why it ranks ninth
Griffith Xidias has operated since 1993 and clients who connect with Matt Griffith describe skilled, successful work, with staff member Patty specifically praised for approachability. The firm's long tenure in real estate and business law is real, but service consistency is the tradeoff.
Pros
- Recognized expertise in real estate and business law
- Successful case outcomes reported
- Staff described as honest and approachable
- Operating in Indianapolis since 1993
Watch out: Other reviewers describe weeks of unanswered calls and unfinished work despite a paid retainer.
Services: foreclosure defense litigation, loan modification loss mitigation, legal services, foreclosure service
Mann Law, P.C. Attorneys at Law
Why it ranks tenth
Mann Law has helped a number of clients resolve property matters fast and for less money, and staff get credit for knowledge on property transfers. With 51 reviews at a 3.9 average, the record shows real wins alongside real friction points once a case is underway.
Pros
- Fast resolution reported by several clients
- Experienced staff on property transfers
- Polite, professional first impressions
Watch out: Multiple reviewers describe poor follow-up after hiring, unclear billing, and having to chase status updates themselves.
Services: loan modification loss mitigation, legal services, real estate title issues, foreclosure service
Thomas Rothe, Attorney at Law
Why it ranks #11
Thomas Rothe draws a small but consistent set of five-star reviews describing him as knowledgeable and detail-oriented, including repeat and family-referred clients for bankruptcy and consultation work. The sample is just three reviews, so weigh this as an early positive signal rather than a broad track record.
Pros
- Consistent praise for detail-oriented advice
- Family referrals and repeat clients
Watch out: Only three reviews on record, so there's limited data to judge consistency at scale.
Services: loan modification loss mitigation, foreclosure defense litigation, legal services, foreclosure service
Taft Stettinius & Hollister LLP
Why it ranks #12
Taft Stettinius & Hollister brings genuine legal expertise and a multi-state presence, useful when a title dispute crosses state lines or needs specialized resources. The composite score reflects real friction, though, with communication and billing complaints appearing often enough to matter.
Pros
- Experienced attorneys with solid expertise
- Multi-state firm presence and resources
Watch out: Reviewers report slow communication, unresponsive follow-ups, and pricing that shifted between quote and engagement letter, particularly frustrating for time-sensitive matters.
Services: foreclosure defense litigation, free consultation, loan modification loss mitigation, legal services
Whitham, Hebenstreit, and Zubek
Why it ranks #13
Whitham, Hebenstreit, and Zubek has at least one long-time client who returned repeatedly and reported good results each time, which speaks to trust built over multiple matters. The review record is too thin to say much beyond that single detailed account.
Pros
- Repeat client returned multiple times
- Positive outcomes reported
Watch out: Review evidence is limited to essentially one detailed account, so treat this as a low-confidence pick.
Services: loan modification loss mitigation, real estate title issues
Attorney Janet Davis Hocker
Why it ranks #14
Janet Davis Hocker's website points to real estate title experience dating back to 1993, and the single review on file is a five-star rating. There isn't enough review volume yet to say more than that the one data point available is positive.
Pros
- Real estate title experience since 1993
- Serves Indianapolis and statewide Indiana
Watch out: Only one review exists, so this is more a directory listing than a verified track record.
Services: foreclosure defense litigation, free consultation, real estate title issues, loan modification loss mitigation
Irwin J. Prince, Attorney
Why it ranks #15
Irwin J. Prince gets genuine praise for fast, thorough handling of real estate and probate issues from some clients, and comes recommended through other attorney referrals. But the review pattern is volatile, split between five-star praise and one-to-two-star complaints, so this pick comes with real caveats.
Pros
- Fast follow-up when engaged, per some reviewers
- Knowledgeable on real estate and probate matters
Watch out: Other reviewers report unreturned calls, unprepared consultations, upfront fees requested before case review, and filing errors.
Services: foreclosure defense litigation, loan modification loss mitigation, real estate title issues, legal services