Foreclosure attorneys in Castleton (Fishers): top picks
Castleton residents dealing with foreclosure, debt disputes, or real estate title issues have several Fishers-area firms to choose from. The picks below are ranked using our methodology, which weighs review volume, rating trends, and what clients actually say about communication and outcomes.
Foreclosure cases in this area often overlap with real estate paperwork (deed and title work), landlord-tenant disputes, and broader debt or civil litigation, so several firms below handle adjacent real estate and consumer legal matters alongside foreclosure defense.
16 businesses, scored on rating, review volume, recency, sentiment and listing completeness. How we score › · View on map ›
At a glance
| # | Business | Score | Rating | From | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Massillamany Jeter & Carson LLP | 89 | 4.7 (240) | — | Overall track record |
| 2 | Wyant Law | 86 | 4.9 (50) | — | Cases other firms decline |
| 3 | Rollins Law Group | 82 | 4.8 (74) | — | Deed and title paperwork |
| 4 | Shircliff Law LLC | 78 | 4.7 (38) | — | Courtroom-focused defense |
| 5 | RileyCate, LLC | 77 | 4.9 (63) | — | Responsive, high-stakes cases |
| 6 | Smid Law | 73 | 5 (22) | — | Personal attention on smaller caseload |
| 7 | Camden & Meridew, P.C. | 72 | 4.5 (99) | — | Complex, multi-issue cases |
| 8 | Hensley Legal Group, PC | 92 | 4.9 (670) | — | High-volume, proven consistency |
| 9 | Freedman Law, P.C. | 71 | 4.7 (14) | — | free consultation |
| 10 | BFC Realty Group - Brian Campbell Managing Broker/Realtor | 64 | 5 (21) | — | foreclosure service |
| 11 | Emerson Divorce and Accident Injury Attorneys, L.L.C. | 62 | 3.9 (11) | — | loan modification loss mitigation |
| 12 | Church Church Hittle + Antrim (CCHA Law) - Fishers | 61 | 4 (9) | — | loan modification loss mitigation |
| 13 | Bankruptcy Law Office of Matthew D Boruta | 60 | 5 (5) | — | loan modification loss mitigation |
| 14 | Matthew Keyes, Attorney At Law | 57 | 5 (2) | — | free consultation |
| 15 | The Law Office of Nita Gupta | 44 | 1 (1) | — | loan modification loss mitigation |
| 16 | Sell My House Fast Indy | As Is Cash Home Buyers Fishers | 30 | — | — | foreclosure service |
Ranked picks
Massillamany Jeter & Carson LLP
score 89/100Named attorneys and paralegals earn consistent praise for clear communication and hard-fought advocacy across a high volume of reviews.
Wyant Law
score 86/100Chris Wyant is known for taking on tough disputes and staying personally responsive through lengthy negotiations.
Rollins Law Group
score 82/100Fast, clearly explained deed recording and title updates, though reviewers note the firm works with landlords rather than tenants.
Shircliff Law LLC
score 78/100David Shircliff delivers strong dismissals when a case gets his full attention, per reviewers, though a few noted uneven focus during busy periods.
RileyCate, LLC
score 77/100Dave Seiter, Russell Cate, and Sundeep Singh are praised for quick contact and strong results, though a couple of older reviews flag inconsistent follow-through.
Smid Law
score 73/100A perfect 5-star record from 22 reviewers who highlight quick responses and thorough guidance from Edward Smid and Emily Kopp.
Camden & Meridew, P.C.
score 72/100A deep team spanning family, real estate, tax, and civil matters gets praise for tackling high-stakes situations, despite one flagged follow-up lapse.
Hensley Legal Group, PC
score 92/100Nearly 700 reviews back up a reputation for clear case updates and dependable communication from staff like Briceida Ortega and Melanie Diaz.
Freedman Law, P.C.
score 71/100Freedman Law earns strong marks for attorney expertise, clear communication, and genuine care in complex family law cases.
BFC Realty Group - Brian Campbell Managing Broker/Realtor
score 64/100Brian Campbell and BFC Realty Group close transactions smoothly across buying, selling, and property management in Indianapolis.
Emerson Divorce and Accident Injury Attorneys, L.L.C.
score 62/100Early clients praised the team's knowledge and availability, but recent reviews show sharp disagreement.
Church Church Hittle + Antrim (CCHA Law) - Fishers
score 61/100Five of nine reviewers rated the firm highly, citing clear communication and staff professionalism; Sarah Randall and Leslie Henderzahs were named for creating comfortable client experiences.
Bankruptcy Law Office of Matthew D Boruta
score 60/100All five reviews rate Matt Boruta five stars and highlight his knowledge, responsiveness, and genuine care for clients.
Matthew Keyes, Attorney At Law
score 57/100One reviewer praised Matthew Keyes for fighting hard on the case, staying in touch, and charging fairly.
The Law Office of Nita Gupta
score 44/100Not enough recent reviews yet to synthesise a reliable sentiment read for this business.
Sell My House Fast Indy | As Is Cash Home Buyers Fishers
score 30/100Not enough recent reviews yet to synthesise a reliable sentiment read for this business.