Indianapolis Metro Foreclosure Attorney Guide
Menu

Law Office of Gary L. Colasessano LLC

Updated 2026-08-27 · 5,377 reviewed · 200 listed · Scored from 33 Google reviews · How we rank ›

4.7(33) 78 composite score See reviews on Google ✓ Google-verified
Loan Modification & Loss MitigationLegal ServicesForeclosure Service
Law Office of Gary L. Colasessano LLC
Services
Loan Modification & Loss Mitigation, Legal Services, Foreclosure Service
Reviews
33

What recent reviews say

Gary Colasessano earns consistent praise for criminal defense work, with clients describing him as attentive, knowledgeable, and driven by genuine care rather than profit. He calls back quickly, explains strategy clearly, and negotiates deals that spare clients from year-long probation, heavy fines, or court appearances. His rates are described as fair compared to competitors.

A handful of complaints surface: one client reports Gary admitted seeing bodycam footage but never mailed it as promised; another says staff hung up when asked about Spanish-language services; a third mentioned rude receptionists. Most clients credit Gary directly with excellent outcomes and describe feeling protected and informed throughout proceedings.

Praised for
  • responsive, direct communication
  • compassionate and genuinely invested
  • knowledgeable in criminal law and Indiana system
  • strong negotiation outcomes
  • affordable rates
Watch-outs
  • staff rudeness, inconsistent service quality
  • unethical language barrier dismissal
  • failure to deliver promised evidence
responsive-communicationknowledgeablecompassionatesuccessful-outcomeclear-explanationsexperienced-attorneypersonalized-attentionprofessional-staffhonest-advice
Best for: Criminal defendants seeking negotiated outcomes who value direct communication and affordable representation.
Think twice if: Front desk responsiveness is inconsistent; ask directly about staff reliability before hiring.

Strengths

  • Quick callback times
  • Fair pricing compared to competitors
  • Negotiates reduced sentences and probation
  • Handles cases without requiring client court appearances

Worth knowing

  • Gary Colasessano handles criminal cases without requiring client courtroom presence in some situations
  • Claims over 30 years of practice
  • Staff member Jesse noted positively by one client but same client criticized support team
  • One client reports Gary admitted seeing bodycam footage but failed to mail promised hard drive copy

What reviews say by service

Legal Services
Clients consistently praise criminal defense strategy, explanation, and negotiation; one complaint about staff rudeness and unethical language barrier dismissal.

How it compares

  • Rated 4.7 against a 4.53 average across the 158 legal services businesses listed here.
  • Has more Google reviews than 61% of the businesses in this directory.

How we scored this

Ranking Method
Star rating 75
Review volume 66
Review recency 100
Review sentiment 67
Profile completeness 100
Verification 30

Rating breakdown

5
30
4
0
3
1
2
1
1
1

Common questions

Will I have to appear in court?
Not always. One client reported Gary handled their case so thoroughly with the prosecutor that they avoided court appearances entirely. Results vary by case.
How quickly will Gary call me back?
Reviewers report callbacks within minutes of leaving a voicemail.
What areas does Gary serve?
Indianapolis, Marion County, and the Greater Indianapolis area. His website lists criminal defense experience including DUI, drug crimes, domestic violence, battery, assault, and juvenile cases.

Similar foreclosure attorneys nearby

Bymaster Bankruptcy Law Offices
71 low data

Bymaster Bankruptcy Law Offices

4.8(24)✓ Google-verified

Most clients praise the office for making bankruptcy filings approachable and stress-free, with staff who listen and explain steps clearly. One older complaint about unanswered phone calls stands out against consistent praise for professionalism and flexibility.

Bankruptcy (Chapter 7 & 13)Loan Modification & Loss MitigationDebt Collection Defense
Ben Buys Indy Houses
81

Ben Buys Indy Houses

4.6(296)✓ Google-verified

Sellers describe a straightforward process from first call to close. Craig Moore and team members like Lacey, Karly, and Josh consistently explain what will happen, show up on time, and deliver. Many closed in a month despite difficult circumstances: hoarding, fire damage, probate, foreclosure. They answer phones personally and adjust pace to seller needs rather than rush. One neighbor reported abandoned property conditions tied to the company. Most feedback emphasizes honesty about offers, fair prices for damaged homes, and the relief of selling quickly without renovation burden. Staff names appear across dozens of reviews as reliable and kind, not transactional.

Free ConsultationForeclosure Service
Dutton Legal Group LLC
78

Dutton Legal Group LLC

4.7(31)✓ Google-verified

Dutton Legal Group has resolved years-long tax troubles for most reviewers, with clients consistently praising Mark Dutton and his team's expertise and responsiveness. The single poor review stands apart: that client felt the firm accepted the IRS's position rather than advocate on their behalf, resulting in no real benefit.

Debt Collection DefenseForeclosure Defense & LitigationFree Consultation

Own this business? Get featured

Own or market a business here? Ask about featured placement and advertising on this directory. Your message goes straight to the directory team.

Last updated 2026-08-27