Indianapolis Metro Foreclosure Attorney Guide
Menu

Keffer Hirschauer LLP

Updated 2026-08-27 · 5,377 reviewed · 200 listed · Scored from 273 Google reviews · How we rank ›

4.5(273) 77 composite score See reviews on Google ✓ Google-verified
Foreclosure Defense & LitigationFree ConsultationLoan Modification & Loss MitigationLegal ServicesForeclosure Service
Keffer Hirschauer LLP
Services
Foreclosure Defense & Litigation, Free Consultation, Loan Modification & Loss Mitigation
Reviews
273

What recent reviews say

Many clients report strong outcomes and attentive representation when actively communicating with their attorney. The firm excels at explaining complex legal matters and delivering results on matters from gun rights restoration to Title IX cases. However, numerous complaints document communication breakdowns after initial engagement, abrupt staff changes without notification, unclear retainer policies, and cases that went unfiled despite payment. Retainer structures appear to frustrate clients unfamiliar with trust account practices.

The firm's size and staff variability (clients name Bradley Keffer, Myekeal Wynn, Peter Capofari, Gregory Morser, Caroline, Rachel, Melissa Middleton) create uneven experiences. Some praise thoroughness and compassion; others report abandonment, ghosting, or minimal effort on straightforward matters. Billing transparency and consistent follow-through remain persistent weak points.

Praised for
  • responsive communication when engaged
  • clear explanation of legal processes
  • successful outcomes on cases handled
  • staff compassion during stressful situations
Watch-outs
  • communication lapses after engagement
  • unclear billing practices and retainers
  • staff transitions without client notice
  • lack of case follow-through and documentation
responsive-communicationknowledgeablecompassionateclear-explanationssuccessful-outcomepoor-communicationunresponsivedelayed-casemissed-deadlinesexpensive-fees
Best for: clients seeking specialized expertise in criminal defense or Title IX who can afford larger retainers and verify attorney assignment upfront.
Think twice if: you value frequent direct contact with your attorney; this firm has documented communication gaps, staff turnover without notice, and unclear retainer practices.

Strengths

  • knowledgeable attorneys on specialized law (Title IX, gun rights)
  • successful case outcomes when actively engaged
  • clear legal explanations and strategy
  • some staff noted for compassion and attentiveness

Worth knowing

  • Named attorneys include Bradley Keffer, Myekeal Wynn, Peter Capofari, Gregory Morser, and Caroline
  • Clients report being switched between attorneys without prior notice
  • One attorney's license noted as suspended in a review
  • Staff transitions (e.g., Melissa Middleton departure) occurred without client notification
  • Clients praise staff members Rachel and Caroline for attentiveness

What reviews say by service

Foreclosure Defense & Litigation
Limited review evidence; no specific foreclosure outcomes described.
Free Consultation
Consultations offered but some clients report inadequate upfront explanation of retainer and billing structure.
Legal Services
Strong outcomes praised on Title IX and gun rights cases; criminal defense success noted but marred by communication failures on other matters.
Loan Modification & Loss Mitigation
No review evidence specific to this service.
Foreclosure Service
No review evidence specific to this service.

How it compares

  • Rated 4.5 against a 4.5 average across the 88 foreclosure defense & litigation businesses listed here.
  • Has more Google reviews than 92% of the businesses in this directory.

How we scored this

Ranking Method
Star rating 67
Review volume 100
Review recency 100
Review sentiment 48
Profile completeness 100
Verification 30

Rating breakdown

5
226
4
7
3
6
2
6
1
28

Common questions

Does Keffer Hirschauer offer a free consultation?
Reviews reference consultations, but do not state whether they are free or paid.
What is the typical billing structure?
The firm uses retainer trust accounts, but clients report confusion about how retainers apply to hourly rates and refund policies. Upfront clarification is advised before engaging.
Will I work with the same attorney throughout my case?
Clients report being assigned different attorneys and shifted between staff without prior notice, so continuity is not guaranteed.

Similar foreclosure attorneys nearby

Whitham, Hebenstreit, and Zubek
57 low data

Whitham, Hebenstreit, and Zubek

4.3(4)

A long-time client returned multiple times for legal help and reported good results each time. Review evidence is limited to one detailed account.

Loan Modification & Loss MitigationReal Estate & Title Disputes
Eskew Law
86

Eskew Law

4.7(251)✓ Google-verified

Clients consistently experience confident, prepared representation backed by attorneys who take personal interest in their outcomes. Named attorneys (Yasmin Abdelhak Barker, Christopher Eskew, Ben Jaffee, Heather Franklin) and staff earn praise for explaining legal strategy, handling custody and family cases swiftly, and delivering courtroom wins; one negative review flags intake staff for unresponsiveness and unclear case-determination processes. Their website lists criminal defense expertise (DUI, drug, assault, fraud, expungement), though recent reviews focus on family law and criminal outcomes. Service areas span Indianapolis to Fort Wayne. The firm claims over 75 years combined experience.

Loan Modification & Loss MitigationLegal ServicesForeclosure Service
Taft Stettinius & Hollister LLP
58 low data

Taft Stettinius & Hollister LLP

3.5(23)✓ Google-verified

Large firm attracts strong praise for expertise but faces repeated complaints about slow communication, unresponsive staff, and billing inconsistencies. Time-sensitive matters and small-town clients report particular friction with delays and lack of follow-up.

Foreclosure Defense & LitigationFree ConsultationLoan Modification & Loss Mitigation

Own this business? Get featured

Own or market a business here? Ask about featured placement and advertising on this directory. Your message goes straight to the directory team.

Last updated 2026-08-27