Indianapolis Metro Foreclosure Attorney Guide
Menu
Talk to an attorney Call

Forsythe Law

Updated 2026-08-27 · 5,377 reviewed · 200 listed · Scored from 17 Google reviews · How we rank ›

4.8(17) 73 low data composite score See reviews on Google ✓ Google-verified
Debt Collection DefenseLegal ServicesFree ConsultationLoan Modification & Loss MitigationReal Estate & Title Disputes
Forsythe Law
Services
Debt Collection Defense, Legal Services, Free Consultation
Reviews
17

What recent reviews say

Matt Forsythe answers his own phone and explains what your case will cost before billing you. Reviewers highlight his willingness to fight cases other attorneys turn down, his clear updates through settlement or appeal, and his personal attention even on complex matters spanning years.

Based on limited recent reviews, so treat this as low-confidence.

Praised for
  • responsive, direct communication
  • takes cases others refuse
  • transparent about legal options
  • treats clients with respect
Watch-outs
  • slow response to emails
  • poor client communication
responsive-communicationknowledgeablecompassionatesuccessful-outcomeclear-explanationsexperienced-attorneypersonalized-attentionhonest-advice
Best for: clients needing personal injury or insurance representation who value direct access to their attorney
Think twice if: settlement cases may take extended time to resolve; one reviewer reported slow email response and two-year wait

Strengths

  • takes rejected cases seriously
  • direct lawyer-client relationship (answers own phone)
  • transparent about costs and outcomes
  • long-term case commitment

Worth knowing

  • Matthew Forsythe answers his own phone and does not bill for casual conversation
  • collaborates with colleagues Mark Metzger and Dave Lelek on cases
  • has represented clients through district court, court of appeals, and settlement negotiations
  • took on slip and fall case when other firms declined

What reviews say by service

Legal Services
reviewers praise his handling of auto insurance appeals, lease disputes, slip and fall cases, and complex multi-year litigation with successful outcomes
Free Consultation
one reviewer noted Matt listened patiently to their situation and offered to assist without stated barriers

How it compares

  • Rated 4.8 against a 4.55 average across the 87 real estate & title disputes businesses listed here.
  • Has more Google reviews than 45% of the businesses in this directory.

How we scored this

Ranking Method
Star rating 76
Review volume 55
Review recency 94
Review sentiment 59
Profile completeness 100
Verification 30

Rating breakdown

5
16
4
0
3
0
2
0
1
1

Common questions

Does Matthew Forsythe handle insurance cases?
Yes. Reviewers specifically mention auto insurance appeals and insurance company disputes as cases he takes on even when other lawyers decline.
Will I be billed for preliminary conversations with the attorney?
No. One long-term client reports Matthew does not invoice for casual conversation, a contrast to some law firms.
Request a quote

Similar foreclosure attorneys nearby

McManus & Associates
87

McManus & Associates

5.0(47)✓ Google-verified

Clients consistently describe John McManus as a skilled, patient advocate who strips bankruptcy of its stigma and stress. He explains proceedings in plain language, answers questions without overwhelming detail, and remains available long after cases close. Several reviewers noted he provided free guidance even when unable to take their case, and one longstanding client reports he still remembers and assists them nearly a decade later.

Bankruptcy (Chapter 7 & 13)Loan Modification & Loss MitigationDebt Collection Defense
View profile
Dennis, Wenger & Abrell, P.C.
70 low data

Dennis, Wenger & Abrell, P.C.

4.6(9)✓ Google-verified

Most reviewers praise Mary Wisehart and her team for responsiveness, clear communication, and genuine empathy through difficult family law matters. One complaint alleges employment law was advertised but unavailable, suggesting service scope questions warrant clarification before hiring.

Debt Collection DefenseLoan Modification & Loss MitigationReal Estate & Title Disputes
View profile
Terry Legal Group, LLC
68 low data

Terry Legal Group, LLC

4.5(74)✓ Google-verified

Most reviewers praise John Terry and Kim Lytle for patient, knowledgeable guidance and willingness to help even outside their scope. However, recent complaints name specific attorneys (Sarah Shields, Stephenie Gookins) for poor effort, disrespect, and inadequate advocacy. Review depth is limited to recent topics and named staff.

Loan Modification & Loss MitigationForeclosure Defense & LitigationReal Estate & Title Disputes
View profile

Own this business? Get featured

Own or market a business here? Ask about featured placement and advertising on this directory. Your message goes straight to the directory team.

Last updated 2026-08-27