Strong advocates when engaged: Erin and Catherine's team provide emotional support, clear explanations, and thorough attention during cases. But inconsistent follow-up and a pattern of pursuing their own case strategy over client wishes have left some clients waiting for calls that never came and wondering if the firm prioritizes quick wins over long-term outcomes.
Based on limited recent reviews, so treat this as low-confidence.
Simple Quarters staff-especially Jajaira, Roxanne, and James-consistently deliver speed and genuine care through home transactions. Reviewers repeatedly note quick responses, follow-through on promises, and a team that treats clients as individuals rather than transactions, even covering repairs and staying involved after closing.
All 28 reviews are five-star. Clients praise Mr. Johnston's deep real estate knowledge, genuine concern for their outcomes, and quick responsiveness. He avoids unnecessary litigation, communicates clearly, and handles complex property issues from foreclosure alternatives to commercial closings and HOA disputes. Repeat clients and professional referrers value his reasonable fees and willingness to work intensively on cases that initially seemed difficult.
Jillian Keating handles family law, criminal defense, and related matters across the Indianapolis metro. All six reviews praise her responsiveness, legal skill, and trustworthiness; clients note she delivers outcomes that exceed expectations and takes time to explain their options honestly.
Last updated 2026-08-27