Indianapolis Metro Foreclosure Attorney Guide
Menu

Foreclosure attorneys in Mile Square, Indianapolis: top picks

Mile Square sits at the center of Indianapolis, close to the courts and the firms that handle foreclosure, bankruptcy, and related financial cases for the whole metro. The attorneys below range from dedicated bankruptcy practices to full-service firms that also take on foreclosure-adjacent matters, ranked using our methodology based on client sentiment, responsiveness, and case outcomes.

Several of these offices sit within walking distance of the Marion County courthouse and City-County Building, which matters for filings and hearings tied to foreclosure and bankruptcy proceedings in the area.

25 businesses, scored on rating, review volume, recency, sentiment and listing completeness. How we score › · View on map ›

At a glance

#BusinessScoreRatingFromBest for
1Hayes Law Office934.9 (350)Straight talk, flat fees
2Law Office of Mark S. Zuckerberg904.8 (208)Chapter 7, 13, and foreclosure filings
3Law Office of Jeff Cardella Criminal Defense Attorney & Expungement Lawyer in Indianapolis Indiana874.8 (164)Fast expungements
4Gemma & Karimi - Indianapolis Criminal Defense Lawyers864.9 (126)Round-the-clock communication
5CohenMalad, LLP854.7 (188)Named-attorney continuity
6Conrad Legal LLC824.8 (47)Plain-language bankruptcy guidance
7The Kryder Law Group, LLC Accident and Injury Lawyers825 (54)Injury-adjacent claims
8Perez & Perez Bankruptcy814.7 (72)Upfront pricing on bankruptcy
9Heritage Cash Home Buyers784.9 (63)foreclosure service
10HKM Employment Attorneys LLP774.5 (65)loan modification loss mitigation
11Ebbinghouse Law Group LLC754.9 (18)loan modification loss mitigation
12Peter Francis Geraci Law L.L.C.734.9 (91)bankruptcy chapter 7 13
13Jerry E. Smith644.6 (32)loan modification loss mitigation
14The Law Office of Travis Van Winkle, LLC634 (37)bankruptcy chapter 7 13
15Bose McKinney & Evans LLP623.7 (12)loan modification loss mitigation
16Hackman Hulett, LLP615 (6)real estate title issues
17Law Office of Fatima Skimin614.7 (13)loan modification loss mitigation
18Taft Stettinius & Hollister LLP583.5 (23)foreclosure defense litigation
19Ryan O'Connell Attorney At Law575 (7)free consultation
20DTurner Legal, LLC704.6 (73)debt collection defense
21Lewis Legal Services674.2 (27)free consultation
22UpRight Law481 (1)loan modification loss mitigation
23Indiana Property Rights: Eminent Domain Attorneys32foreclosure defense litigation
24Rochelle McCullough PLLC30foreclosure defense litigation
25Whitford & Owen PLLC26bankruptcy chapter 7 13

Ranked picks

1
Hayes Law Office

Hayes Law Office

score 93/100
4.9 from 350 reviews
Straight talkflat feeshonest adviceresponsive communication

Clients say Hayes Law Office gets charges dismissed on cases other lawyers called hopeless, at flat fees 20-30% below competitors.

2
Law Office of Mark S. Zuckerberg

Law Office of Mark S. Zuckerberg

score 90/100
4.8 from 208 reviews
Chapter 713and foreclosure filingsresponsive communication

Paralegal-led support and same-day callbacks help clients through Chapter 7, Chapter 13, and foreclosure cases with what reviewers call an organized process.

3
Law Office of Jeff Cardella Criminal Defense Attorney & Expungement Lawyer in Indianapolis Indiana

Law Office of Jeff Cardella Criminal Defense Attorney & Expungement Lawyer in Indianapolis Indiana

score 87/100
4.8 from 164 reviews
Fast expungementsresponsive communicationknowledgeablecompassionate

Known for closing expungements in weeks to months, though a couple of reviews mention brusque phone handling and selective case acceptance.

4
Gemma & Karimi - Indianapolis Criminal Defense Lawyers

Gemma & Karimi - Indianapolis Criminal Defense Lawyers

score 86/100
4.9 from 126 reviews
Round-the-clock communicationresponsive communicationknowledgeablecompassionate

Kevin Karimi's team answers late-night calls and won dismissals and reduced sentences, though a few reviews cite high retainers and one missed court date.

5
CohenMalad, LLP

CohenMalad, LLP

score 85/100
4.7 from 188 reviews
Named-attorney continuityresponsive communicationknowledgeablecompassionate

A large firm where clients single out attorneys like Jeff Hammond and Greg Laker by name for clear updates, despite one flagged communication complaint.

6
Conrad Legal LLC

Conrad Legal LLC

score 82/100
4.8 from 47 reviews
Plain-language bankruptcy guidanceresponsive communicationknowledgeablecompassionate

Matt Conrad walks clients through options, including referrals when a case falls outside his scope, at reasonable rates.

7
The Kryder Law Group, LLC Accident and Injury Lawyers

The Kryder Law Group, LLC Accident and Injury Lawyers

score 82/100
5 from 54 reviews
Injury-adjacent claimsprofessional staff

A perfect rating from a small review pool, with clients praising a responsive team on their case.

8
Perez & Perez Bankruptcy

Perez & Perez Bankruptcy

score 81/100
4.7 from 72 reviews
Upfront pricing on bankruptcyresponsive communicationknowledgeablecompassionate

Jay Perez lays out costs and timelines clearly and resolves cases in months, though a handful of clients report slower responses or fee disputes.

9
Heritage Cash Home Buyers

Heritage Cash Home Buyers

score 78/100
4.9 from 63 reviews
foreclosure serviceresponsive communicationknowledgeablecompassionate

Heritage closes sales quickly, typically within 30 days, and earns consistent praise for open communication and transparent dealing.

10
HKM Employment Attorneys LLP

HKM Employment Attorneys LLP

score 77/100
4.5 from 65 reviews
loan modification loss mitigationresponsive communicationknowledgeablecompassionate

Most clients praise HKM's attorneys, especially Ben Ellis and Katie Bensberg, for taking time to explain cases thoroughly, responding promptly, and achieving positive outcomes.

11
Ebbinghouse Law Group LLC

Ebbinghouse Law Group LLC

score 75/100
4.9 from 18 reviews
loan modification loss mitigationknowledgeableresponsive communicationcompassionate

Rick Ebbinghouse and his firm resolve complex tax problems, from IRS audits and wage garnishment to filing corrections, with consistent clarity and emotional support.

12
Peter Francis Geraci Law L.L.C.

Peter Francis Geraci Law L.L.C.

score 73/100
4.9 from 91 reviews
bankruptcy chapter 7 13responsive communicationknowledgeablecompassionate

Most clients report a major shift in confidence and reduced stress after working with this firm.

13
Jerry E. Smith

Jerry E. Smith

score 64/100
4.6 from 32 reviews
loan modification loss mitigationresponsive communicationknowledgeablecompassionate

Most reviewers praise Smith's responsiveness, knowledge of bankruptcy and debt relief, and ability to ease the stress of financial crisis.

14
The Law Office of Travis Van Winkle, LLC

The Law Office of Travis Van Winkle, LLC

score 63/100
4 from 37 reviews
bankruptcy chapter 7 13knowledgeablepersonalized attentionclear explanations

Most reviewers praise Travis Van Winkle's legal knowledge, courtroom composure, and ability to explain complex matters clearly.

15
Bose McKinney & Evans LLP

Bose McKinney & Evans LLP

score 62/100
3.7 from 12 reviews
loan modification loss mitigationknowledgeableprofessional staffdelayed case

Strong praise from satisfied clients centers on named attorneys who pursue cases with personal investment and deep legal knowledge.

16
Hackman Hulett, LLP

Hackman Hulett, LLP

score 61/100
5 from 6 reviews
real estate title issuesresponsive communicationknowledgeablehonest advice

Reviewers highlight Attorney Peter Ten Eyck's ability to untangle complex, years-long legal problems that other lawyers had left unresolved.

17
Law Office of Fatima Skimin

Law Office of Fatima Skimin

score 61/100
4.7 from 13 reviews
loan modification loss mitigationknowledgeablepersonalized attentionresponsive communication

Most clients praise Skimin's availability, bankruptcy expertise, and willingness to work urgent cases like Thanksgiving filings.

18
Taft Stettinius & Hollister LLP

Taft Stettinius & Hollister LLP

score 58/100
3.5 from 23 reviews
foreclosure defense litigationunresponsivepoor communicationhidden fees

Large firm attracts strong praise for expertise but faces repeated complaints about slow communication, unresponsive staff, and billing inconsistencies.

19
Ryan O'Connell Attorney At Law

Ryan O'Connell Attorney At Law

score 57/100
5 from 7 reviews
free consultationpersonalized attentionknowledgeableaggressive advocacy

All seven reviews rate Ryan O'Connell five stars.

20
DTurner Legal, LLC

DTurner Legal, LLC

score 70/100
4.6 from 73 reviews
debt collection defenseaggressive advocacysuccessful outcomeresponsive communication

Denise Turner's firm wins significant cases: charges dismissed, habitual offender charges dropped, murder charges reduced to lesser felonies, house arrest modifications granted.

21
Lewis Legal Services

Lewis Legal Services

score 67/100
4.2 from 27 reviews
free consultationresponsive communicationcompassionatehonest advice

Tom Lewis draws strong loyalty from satisfied clients who praise his quick response times, genuine care, and reasonable fees, with many reporting successful outcomes in criminal and family cases.

22
UpRight Law

UpRight Law

score 48/100
1 from 1 reviews
loan modification loss mitigation

Not enough recent reviews yet to synthesise a reliable sentiment read for this business.

23
Indiana Property Rights: Eminent Domain Attorneys

Indiana Property Rights: Eminent Domain Attorneys

score 32/100
foreclosure defense litigation

Review evidence is limited.

24
Rochelle McCullough PLLC

Rochelle McCullough PLLC

score 30/100
foreclosure defense litigation

Review evidence is limited.

25
Whitford & Owen PLLC

Whitford & Owen PLLC

score 26/100
bankruptcy chapter 7 13

Not enough recent reviews yet to synthesise a reliable sentiment read for this business.

Last updated 2026-08-27