Foreclosure attorneys in Castleton (Indianapolis): who to call
Foreclosure is one of those legal problems where the clock matters as much as the strategy, and Castleton homeowners have several Indianapolis-area firms to choose from that handle bankruptcy and foreclosure defense alongside broader debt relief work. The picks below are ranked using our methodology, which weighs review volume, recency, and sentiment rather than star rating alone. A few firms here specialize outside foreclosure, so check the notes to find the right fit for your situation.
Several of these firms operate from multiple Indianapolis-area offices and routinely work with Castleton and broader Marion County clients on Chapter 7 and Chapter 13 filings tied to mortgage default, alongside straight foreclosure defense.
10 businesses, scored on rating, review volume, recency, sentiment and listing completeness. How we score › · View on map ›
At a glance
| # | Business | Score | Rating | From | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Darrell J. Dolan Attorney At Law | 87 | 5 (52) | — | Hands-on, personal attorney service |
| 2 | Law Offices of Eugene Mogilevsky | 87 | 4.8 (281) | — | High-volume, responsive practice |
| 3 | McManus & Associates | 87 | 5 (47) | — | First-time filers who want plain-language guidance |
| 4 | Jackson & Oglesby Law LLC | 86 | 4.9 (88) | — | Clients who want a responsive paralegal on their case |
| 5 | Barnes Cadwell Law | 77 | 5 (18) | — | Estate and contract matters alongside debt issues |
| 6 | Peter Francis Geraci Law L.L.C. | 76 | 5 (102) | — | Straightforward foreclosure and bankruptcy filings |
| 7 | Clapp Ferrucci | 68 | 4.1 (13) | — | Real estate and eminent domain disputes |
| 8 | The Law Office of Mitchell E. Pippin, P.C. | 65 | 4.8 (8) | — | Direct access to a single attorney |
| 9 | Fisher Maas Howard Lloyd & Wheeler P.C. | 49 | 4 (4) | — | debt collection defense |
| 10 | Indy Home Help | 30 | — | — | loan modification loss mitigation |
Ranked picks
Darrell J. Dolan Attorney At Law
score 87/100Clients say Dolan handles cases himself and responds within 24 hours, with strong praise for staff support during Chapter 7 filings.
Law Offices of Eugene Mogilevsky
score 87/100Nearly 300 reviews and fast 24-hour answers, though quality reportedly varies more outside immigration cases.
McManus & Associates
score 87/100Reviewers describe John McManus as patient and available long after cases close, even offering free guidance when he couldn't take a case.
Jackson & Oglesby Law LLC
score 86/100Paralegal Stacey Burkhard is repeatedly praised for fast, thorough answers, though one reviewer noted a missed initial appointment.
Barnes Cadwell Law
score 77/100All recent reviews are five-star, with Marty Barnes and Jeff Cadwell praised for patient, transparent handling of complex documents.
Peter Francis Geraci Law L.L.C.
score 76/100All 102 Google reviews are five-star, with staff praised for explaining foreclosure options clearly and treating clients without judgment.
Clapp Ferrucci
score 68/100Most reviewers praise responsiveness and cost-conscious advice, though two flagged refused consultations and withheld case materials.
The Law Office of Mitchell E. Pippin, P.C.
score 65/100Mitch Pippin gets praise for fast callbacks and staying in contact through Chapter 7 and 13 cases, based on a small review set.
Fisher Maas Howard Lloyd & Wheeler P.C.
score 49/100Four Google reviews show a sharp split: half praise the firm's warmth and care, while half report being left in the dark about case progress and having little say in strategy.
Indy Home Help
score 30/100Not enough recent reviews yet to synthesise a reliable sentiment read for this business.